HEC PRESS Publisher of the
Healthy Eating Club website &
A
sia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition

 


Volume 16 (2007)
1 Issue 1
1 Issue 2
1 Issue 3
1 Issue 4
1 Supplement 1
1 Supplement 2
Volume 15 (2006)
Issue 1
Issue 2
Issue 3
Issue 4
Supplement
Nutrition Society of Australia
Volume 14 (2005)
Issue 1
Supplement on CD
IUNS/APCNS proceedings
Issue 2
Issue 3
Issue 4
Supplement
Nutrition Society of Australia
CURRENT YEAR ISSUES
LOGIN to FULL PAPERS
subscribers only
PAST ISSUES
View full papers (free)
CD-Rom AU$190 vol1-13
NUTRITION SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA 1976-
View Abstracts
Search our site
 
1000 Asia Pacific J Clin Nutr (1995) 4: 265-269

Asia Pacific J Clin Nutr (1995) 4: 265-269

The effects of McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken and Pizza Hut meals on recommended diets

Nasseem M Malouf, PhD, APD, Stephen Colagiuri, FRACP

Diabetes Centre, Prince of Wales, Sydney, Australia


The objective was to study the effect of three common takeaway meals on recommended healthy diets. New South Wales Department of Health recommended diets of 5020, 6275, 9205 and 12,540 kilojoules were used. An evening meal from each of these diets was substituted with one of three common fast food chain takeaway meals 1, 2, 3 and 5 times per week. The 3 takeaway meals were from McDonalds, Pizza Hut and Kentucky Fried Chicken. The effects of each of these meals on average daily kilojoule, fibre, fat, P/S ratio, protein and carbohydrate intakes were assessed.

The takeaway meals were high in fat and kilojoules and low in fibre and therefore contravened the Dietary Guidelines for Australians. Addition of these meals increased average kilojoule consumption and the percentage energy contribution of fat and decreased the P/S ratio and fibre intake. The magnitude of these deleterious effects was directly proportional to the number of times the meals were included each week and inversely proportional to the energy content of the diet. The adverse effects were greatest with the McDonalds and Kentucky Fried Chicken meals.

Takeaway meals may be convenient but the meals which were tested were too high in fat and kilojoules and too low in fibre to be a regular part of a balanced diet. Even one takeaway meal per week adversely affects the lower kilojoule recommended healthy diets.


Introduction:

Compared with recommended dietary guidelines, the Australian diet is high in fat, low in complex carbohydrate and low in fibre1,2. The Dietary Guidelines for Australians3 encourage eating less fat, particularly saturated fat, eating more complex carbohydrate, more dietary fibre and controlling body weight.

Social changes over the past 30 years have resulted in an increasing proportion of meals being prepared and eaten outside the home with a 1987 survey showing that Australians spent 28-33% of their food budget on such activities. In recent years, this growth has been most evident in the fast food image chains of which three of the most popular are McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken and Pizza Hut. The number of fast food chain outlets tripled from 398 in 1978 to 1161 in 1987 and accounted for 11% of the money spent on food eaten away from home in the early Eighties1. A survey of 290 adolescents in 1981 showed that 31% ate more than 1 takeaway evening meal per week4 and it is likely that there has been a further increas 1000 e in the consumption of takeaway foods in the past decade. Composite analyses of these takeaway foods indicate that they are generally high in fat, particularly saturated fat, high in kilojoules and low in fibre5,6,7,8.

The potential influence of takeaway foods on the overall health of Australians has not been ascertained. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of three common takeaway meals on recommended healthy diets.

Methods:

New South Wales (NSW) Department of Health Diets9 (5020, 6275, 9205, 12,540 kilojoules (kJ)) were analysed by Homescan10, a computer dietary analysis programme which uses NUTTAB database, the 1990 Nutrition Composition Tables of the Commonwealth Department of Health.

Three takeaway meals, one from each of McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken and Pizza Hut were studied. The composition of the selected meals is shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Takeaway meals studied

McDonalds

Kentucky Fried Chicken

Pizza Hut

1 Big Mac
1 Large Fries (130g)
Regular Thick Shake (325g)

2 Piece Box:
-1 Drumstick (50g)
-1 Thigh (85g)
1 Small Coleslaw (100g)
1 Small Chips (115g)
1 Pepsi (1 can)

3/4 Pizza (Regular Supreme)
1/2 Garlic Bread (49g)
1 Pepsi (1 can)

The evening meal from each of the four Department of Health recommended diets was replaced by each of the takeaway meals one, two, three and five times per week. The effect of the substitution of these takeaway meals for the recommended evening meal was calculated. The revised diet incorporating the takeaway meal(s) was reanalysed using Homescan. The total effect for the week was calculated and then the effect on the daily average intake of protein, fat, carbohydrate, fibre, P/S ratio and kilojoules was derived.

Results:

A sample daily menu for the NSW Department of Health 6275 kJ diet is shown in Table 2 and the analysis of the nutrient content of the four diets is shown in Table 3.

The nutrient analysis of the takeaway meals is shown in Table 4. All meals were high in kilojoules ranging from 4084kJ for Kentucky Fried Chicken to 5292kJ for McDonalds. The McDonalds and Kentucky Fried Chicken meals were high in fat (42.8% and 47.9% of total 1000 kJ respectively) and low in carbohydrate (41% and 38.3% of total kJ respectively). The Pizza Hut meal more closely resembled the recommended dietary guidelines although the kilojoule content was also high at 4516kJ. All 3 meals had an unfavourable P/S ratio ranging from 0.35 for McDonalds to 0.55 for Kentucky Fried Chicken.

Including these 3 takeaway meals in the recommended diets increased total daily kilojoules and qualitatively changed the nutrient composition of the diet. The effects on the 5020 and 12,540kJ diets are shown in Tables 5, 6 and 7. All three takeaway meals resulted in an increased energy and fat intake and decreased the P/S ratio. The effect on energy intake was similar for the 3 meals. However the magnitude of this effect was dependent on the total kilojoule content of the recommended diets. Two McDonalds meals per week increased the kilojoule content of the 5020kJ diet by 23.7% but only increased the 12,540kJ diet by 4.5%. In absolute amounts any two takeaway meals (McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken or Pizza Hut) per week resulted in an average daily increase of nearly 940kJ and 395kJ for the 5020 and 12,540kJ diets respectively. Five takeaway meals per week increased average daily kilojoule intake by 2365 for the 5020kJ diet and 980 for the 12,540kJ diet.

The McDonalds and Kentucky Fried Chicken meals had a greater effect in increasing fat intake compared with the Pizza Hut meal. The McDonalds meal had the most deleterious effect on the P/S ratio. The Pizza Hut meal increased percent carbohydrate content of both the 5020 and the 12,540kJ diets. The other 2 meals (McDonalds and Kentucky Fried Chicken) decreased carbohydrate in the 5020kJ diet and increased carbohydrate in the 12,540kJ diet, however the overall effects were small and none significantly altered the carbohydrate contribution from the recommended range. Fibre content was reduced below recommended levels by the McDonalds and Kentucky Fried Chicken meals for the 5020kJ diet but the effect on the 12,540kJ diet was negligible. No data were available for the fibre content of the Pizza Hut meal.

The above effects were seen at all levels of inclusion of the takeaway meals although the effects were proportional to the number of times each week that the takeaways were included as part of the diet. Even one takeaway meal a week adversely affected the daily composition of the diet averaged over the week but the effect was dependent on total daily kilojoules being most evident with the 5020 kJ diet and least with the 12,540kJ diet.

Table 2. Department of Health Menu 6275 kJ diet
(DA) Daily Allowance Milk

450 ml

  Butter/ margarine

15 g

Breakfast Fruit

1 portion

  Cereal

1 portion

  Bread

1 portion

  Milk

From DA

  Butter/ margarine

From DA

  Tea or coffee

No sugar

Morning Tea Bread, fruit, biscuits

1 portion

  Milk

From DA

  Tea or coffee

No sugar

Lunch Lean meat- or exchange

30 g

  Vegetables or salad

1- 2 serves

  Bread

2 portions

  Butter/ 1000 margarine

From DA

  Fruit

1 portion

  Milk

From DA

  Tea or coffee

No sugar

Afternoon Tea Bread, fruit, biscuits

1 portion

  Milk

From DA

  Tea or coffee

No sugar

Main Meal Lean meat (or exchange)

90 g

  Potato, rice or pasta

1 portion

  Vegetables and/ or salad

2- 3 serves

  Fruit

1 portion

  Bread

1 portion

  Milk

From DA

  Tea or coffee

No sugar

Supper Bread, fruit, biscuits

1 portion

  Milk

From DA

  Tea or coffee

No sugar

Table 3. Composition of NSW Department of Health diets
Nutrient

5020kJ

6275 kJ

9205 kJ

12,540 kJ

Carbohydrate Total (g)

156.7

200.0

281.3

357.3

Complex Carbohydrate

78.2

111.5

188.2

191.4

Sugar

78.5

88.7

93.1

165.9

Protein (g)

61.2

79.5

114.7

176.8

Fat Total (g)

29.8

44.2

74.7

102.6

-Polyunsaturated

10.0

9.4

19.2

26.3

-Monounsaturated

11.1

15.3

25.8

30.8

-Saturated

6.4

16.1

24.3

34.7

Alcohol

0

0

0

0

Fibre (g)

24.7

32.2

36.7

64.8

Cholesterol (mg)

161.4

215.4

312.6

350.0

KiloJoules (kJ)

4760

6160

9167

12795

KiloCalories

1139

1472

2191

3061

Carbohydrate (%kJ)

55.1

52.8

49.9

46.7

Protein (%kJ)

21.4

21.0

20.3

23.1

Fat (%kJ)

23.5

26.2

29.8

30.2

Table 4. Nutrient analysis of the takeaway meals
Nutrient

McDonalds

Pizza Hut

KFC

Carbohydrate Total (g)

133.5

143

95.6

Complex Carbohydrate

73.7

99

41.6

Sugar

59.8

44

54.0

Protein (g)

52.2

49

34.5

Fat Total (g)

61.7

34.5

53.2

-Polyunsaturated

9.4

5.4

9.7

-Monounsaturated

21.9

13.4

23.2

-Saturated

27.0

13.6

17.6

Alcohol

0

0

0

Fibre (g)

4.8

*

7.3

Cholesterol (mg)

128.2

37.2

154.7

KiloJoules (kJ)

5292

4516

4084

KiloCalories

1265

1079

976

Carbohydrate (%kJ)

41

53.1

38.3

Protein (%kJ)

16.2

18.1

13.8

Fat (%kJ)

42.8

28.8

47.9

P/S Ratio

0.35

0.40

0.55

*No data available for fibre content of Pizza Hut meal

Table 5. Average daily effect of the McDonalds meal on the 5020 and 12,540 kJ diets 1000
5020 kJ

Baseline

Takeaways per week

Diet

Diet

1

2

3

5

kJ

4760

5325
(+11.9)

5890
(+23.7)

6455
(+35.6)

7580
(+59.3)

Fat (g)

29.8

37.5

45.3

53.0

68.5

Fat (%)*

23.5

26.5
(+12.8)

28.9
(+23)

30.9
(+31.5)

33.0
(+42.6)

P/S Ratio

1.56

1.13
(-27.6)

0.93
(-40.4)

0.80
(-48.7)

0.67
(-57.1)

CHO*#(%)

55.1

53.7
(-2.5)

52.5
(-4.7)

51.7
(-6.2)

50.2
(-8.9)

Fibre (g)

24.7

24.0
(-2.8)

23.2
(-6.1)

22.5
(-8.9)

21.0
(-15)

12,540 kJ diet
kJ

12,795

13,085
(+2.3)

13,376
(+4.5)

13,670
(+6.8)

14,255
(+11.4)

Fat (g)

102.6

108

113

118

128

Fat (%)*

30.2

31.0
(+2.6)

31.8
(+5.3)

32.5
(+7.6)

33.8
(+11.9)

P/S Ratio

0.76

0.73
(-3.9)

0.69
(-9.2)

0.67
(-11.8)

0.64
(-15.8)

CHO*#.(%)

46.7

46.9
(+0.4)

47.0
(+0.6)

47.1
(+0.9)

47.3
(+1.3)

Fibre (g)

64.8

63.2
(-2.2)

62.0
(-4.3)

60.6
(-6.5)

57.8
(-10.8)

Table 6. Average daily effect of the Kentucky Fried Chicken meal on the 5020 and 12,540 kJ diets
5020 kJ

Baseline

Takeaways per week

Diet

Diet

1

2

3

5

kJ

4760

5150
(+8.2)

5540
(+16.4)

5930
(+24.6)

6710
(+41.0)

Fat (g)

29.8

36.3

42.9

49.4

62.5

Fat (%)*

22.8

26.5
(+12.8)

29.1
(+23.8)

31.3
(+33.2)

35.1
(+49.4)

P/S Ratio

1.56

1.32
(-15.4)

1.17
(-25)

1.07
( 1000 -31.4)

0.95
(-39.1)

CHO*#(%)

55.1

53.8
(-2.4)

52.6
(-4.5)

51.6
(-6.4)

50.0
(-9.3)

Fibre (g)

24.7

24.3
(-1.6)

23.9
(-3.2)

23.6
(-4.5)

22.8
(-7.7)

12,540 kJ diet
kJ

12,795

12910
(+1)

13035
(+1.9)

13150
(+2.8)

13385
(+4.6)

Fat (g)

102.6

106.5

110.4

114

122

1000
Fat (%)*

30.2

31.0
(+2.6)

31.9
(+5.6)

32.6
(+7.9)

34.3
(+13.6)

P/S Ratio

0.76

0.75
(-1.3)

0.75
(-1.3)

0.74
(-2.6)

0.74
(-2.6

CHO*#.(%)

46.8

46.9
(0.2)

46.8
(0)

46.9
(0.2)

47.1
(+.06)

Fibre (g)

64.8

63.7
(-1.7)

62.7
(-3.2)

61.5
(-5.1)

59.4
(-8.3)

1000
Discussion

The Australian diet is high in fat and sugar and low in fibre and complex carbohydrate1. The diets tested in this study are recommended by the NSW Department of Health9 and comply with Dietary Guidelines for Australians3 being low in fat (less than 30% of total kilojoules), high in fibre (at least 25g/ day) and high in complex carbohydrates (approximately 50% of total kilojoules).

Americans now eat one of every three meals outside the home and in 1991 spent 40 billion dollars in fast food outlets11. Similarly, Australians in 1987 spent 30% of the food budget on food eaten away from home1. An increasing proportion of this is being spent on fast foods from image chain outlets. Reasons for this include: increasing numbers of takeaway outlets, marketing of family entertainment, low priced meals, heavy advertising and sponsoring of sporting events.

The takeaway meals studied (Table 1) were selected because they were reported by the respective food chains to be their most common meal packages sold. These meals are energy dense containing 4084 to 5292kJ (Table 4) while the evening meals from the recommended diets contained only 1345kJ for the 5020kJ diet up to 3240kJ for the 12,540kJ diet. Replacing the evening meal of the recommended diets (5020, 6275, 9205 and 12,540kJ) twice a week with the takeaway meals increased daily kilojoule intake by an average 730kJ. This would theoretically translate into an average weight gain of 8.8kg a year if not offset by extra exercise. In a population where overweightness and obesity are prevalent both in adults and adolescents12,13, eating high kilojoule takeaway foods will only accentuate the problem.

The McDonalds and Kentucky Fried Chicken meals are high in fat (42.8% and 47.9% of total kilojoules respectively) and both exceed the recommendation of reducing fat to less than 30% of total kilojoules. The Pizza Hut meal more closely approximated dietary guidelines with a fat content of 28.7%. However, all were high in saturated fat and had an unfavourable P/ S ratio ranging from 0.35 to 0.55. In Australia, a cholesterol of greater than 5.5 mmol/ l is found in 47% of men and 39% of women between the ages of 20 to 69 and hyperlipidaemia is already prevalent in 7 to 15 year old children12,13. Eating takeaway meals is not conducive to curtailing this problem.

 

Table 7. Average daily effect of the Pizza Hut meal on the 5020 and 12,540 kilojoule diets
5020 kJ

Baseline

Takeaways per week

Diet

Diet

1

2

3

5

kJ

4760

5215
(+9.5)

5670
(+19.1)

6120
(+28.5)

7090
(+48.9)

Fat (g)

29.8

33.7

37.6

41.4

49.2

Fat (%)*

22.8

24.3
(+3.4)

25.0
(+6.4)

25.5
(+8.5)

26.1
(+11.1)

P/S Ratio

1.56

1.34
(-14.1)

1.18
(-24.4)

1.06
(-32.1)

0.95
( 1000 -41.7)

CHO*#(%)

55.1

55.2
(+0.2)

55.4
(0.5)

55.5
(+0.7)

55.7
(+1.1)

12,540 kJ diet
kJ

12,795

12975
(+1.4)

13155
(+2.8)

13335
(+4.2)

13690
(+7.0)

Fat (g)

102.6

103.8

105

106.1

108.5

Fat (%)*

30.2

30.1
(-0.3)

30.0
(-0.7)

29.9
(-1.0)

29.7
(-1.7)

P/S Ratio

0.76

1000

0.75
(-1.3)

0.74
(-2.5)

0.73
(-3.9)

0.71
(-6.6)

CHO*#.(%)

46.7

47.5
(+1.7)

48.2
(+3.2)

48.8
(+4.5)

50.1
(+7.3)

Results in tables 5,6,7 are expressed in absolute numbers and percent change are indicated in brackets. * Percent contribution to total energy in the diet # CHO refers to carbohydrate. No data available for fibre content of Pizza Hut meal.

The average Australian presently consumes 19-23 grams of fibre a day2 and it is recommended that this be increased to a minimum of 25 grams. Both the McDonalds and Kentucky Fried Chicken meals have a relatively low fibre content (4.8 and 7.3g respectively) and resulted in a reduction below recommended levels for the 5020kJ diet. While fibre content was reduced with other diets, absolute quantities did not fall below recommended amounts.

Although there is a general adverse effect of including these takeaway foods in the diet, the magnitude of the effect is dependent on the frequency with which the meals are eaten and the total energy of the diet. It is possible for a person who is consuming 12,540kJ per day to substitute 3 evening meals with any of the 3 takeaway meals each week without contravening recommended dietary guidelines. There is, however, one proviso. In this analysis, the takeaway meals were substituted as part of the recommended balanced Department of Health diets, which conform to the Australian Dietary Guidelines. Few Australians, however, conform with these guidelines. The addition of the takeaway meals on the average Australian diet would be expected to have adverse effects significantly beyond those demonstrated in this study.

The results of the analyses on fat, kilojoule and fibre performed in this study are applicable to other meals from these fast food outlets since burgers from McDonalds, pizzas from Pizza Hut or fried chicken from Kentucky Fried Chicken contain the same basic ingredients and utilise the same cooking methods. For example, the fat content of McDonalds burgers ranges from 47 to 55% of total kilojoules6, chicken from Kentucky Fried Chicken from 52 to 64% 8 and Pizza Hut pizzas from 29-35% 7.

It is possible for people with adequate dietary knowledge to select meals from th 1000 ese outlets with less deleterious effects on dietary recommendations. Having half of a Regular Thin Pizza (the filling does not matter) with a large salad (no dressing) and a Diet Pepsi from Pizza Hut provides 1750kJ. A Kentucky Fried Chicken meal of "Chicken N’Salad" (1/4 BBQ bird, stuffing and a small coleslaw) plus mashed potato provides 2190kJ. These carefully selected meals compare favourably, at least in total kilojoules, to evening meals from the recommended diets which ranged from 1345kJ in the 5020kJ diet to 3240kJ in the 12,540kJ diet. However, these takeaway meals remain higher in saturated fat and lower in fibre content.

Our findings indicate that even one of any of these takeaway meals eaten per week can adversely affect the recommended diet especially in those people on a low daily kilojoule diet. Of the fast foods tested, the Pizza Hut meal is the preferred choice since these meals have the lowest fat content and the least deleterious effects on recommended daily nutrient intakes.

Although the exact frequency of usage of takeaway foods by different age groups remains uncertain, it is likely that young Australians are the most frequent consumers. Eating takeaway meals has become part of our society and there is a need to educate consumers, particularly children and parents, about the effect of takeaway foods and their judicious incorporation into the diet to minimise adverse effects. In addition, food outlets could significantly improve the nutrient content of their foods with relatively minor changes including reducing the quantity of fat, cooking in vegetable oils rather than animal fat, introducing salad bars and increasing the fibre content of their breads. Such changes would result in fast food outlets moving towards complying with health department dietary recommendations.

Acknowledgments

We are grateful for the help of Mrs Isabel Ghikas for typing the manuscript.


The effects of McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken and Pizza Hut meals on recommended diets

Nasseem M Malouf PhD, RD; Stephen Colagiuri FRACP

Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition (1995) Volume 4, Number 2: 265-269


References:

  1. Towards Better Nutrition for Australians. 1987. Report of the Nutrition Taskforce of the Better Health Commission. AGPS, Canberra.
  2. National Dietary Survey of Adults, 1983. No. 2. Nutrient Intakes. AGPS, Canberra.
  3. Dietary Guidelines for Australians. 1992. National Health and Medical Research Council. AGPS, Canberra.
  4. Truswell AS and Darnton-Hill I. Food Habits of Australian Adolescents. Nutrition Reviews 1981; 39: 73.
  5. Rogers JF. Take-away Foods Nutritional Significance. Med. J. Aust. 1979; 1: 557.
  6. Wills RBH and Greenfield H. Composition of Australian Foods. 3. Foods from a major fast food chain. Food Technology in Australia. 1980; 32: 363-366.
  7. Greenfield H, Wimalasiri P, Ma SNN and Wills RBH. Composition of Australian Foods. 16. Foods from Pizza Hut restaurants. Food Technology in Australia. 1982; 34: 364-367.
  8. Wills RBH and Greenfield H. 1982. Composition of Australian Foods. 18. Foods from Kentucky Fried Chicken. Food Technology in Australia. 1982; 34: 566-569.
  9. Nutrition Facts Sheet 4 for use in medical practice. Health Information and Translation Services. Department of Health, New South Wales.
  10. Caden M, Colagiuri S, Shannon AG and Gallagher PM. Computerised ambulatory data collection for diabetes management. Diabetes Nutrition and Metabolism. 1991; 4 (Suppl 1): 93-97.
  11. Cordova M And Murphy VL. Fast not fat food. Diabetes Forecast Nov. 1992; 45.
  12. National Heart Foundation of Australia. 1989. Risk Factor Prevalence Study. Survey No.3. National Heart Foundation of Australia and Australian Institute of Health.
  13. Australian Health and Fitness Survey. 1985. The fitness, health and physical performance of Australian school students aged 7-15 years. Australian Council for Health, Physical Education and Recreation (ACHPER).
  14. Wills RBH. and Greenfield H. Nutrient composition of take-away foods. The Australian Health Surveyor 1985; 17: 37-40.


Copyright © 1995 [Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition]. All rights reserved.
Revised: January 19, 1999 .

to the top

0